Back to Case Studies
FOXP215 vertebratesMAFFTComparative ProteinRevised Analysis

Revised FOXP2 Protein Comparison Across 15 Vertebrates

A first-party account of sequence-quality review, complete-sequence replacement, full-alignment analysis, pairwise identity, human-specific substitutions, and the stale legacy section retained in the downloadable report.

Species15
Alignment columns772
Conserved94.0%
Human-specific sites2
01 / Scientific question

What sequence differences remain after curating complete FOXP2 proteins across vertebrates?

The revised analysis compared 14 complete sequences of at least 700 amino acids plus a 693-amino-acid alligator partial sequence. Fragmentary entries in the earlier run were replaced with full cow, pig, and Pteropus bat proteins.

Taxa
Mammals, birds, platypus, and crocodilians
Alignment
Full MAFFT alignment without TrimAl
Identity
Verified on pairwise non-gap positions
Quality exception
Alligator retained as a labeled partial sequence
02 / Managed execution

Sequence curation, full alignment, pairwise verification, and substitution review

Audit sequence lengthsIdentified short fragments and replaced them where complete orthologs were available.
Align complete proteinsRan MAFFT across the revised 15-species set and retained all 772 columns.
Verify identitiesCalculated pairwise identity over positions where both sequences contain amino acids.
Inspect human sitesChecked candidate substitutions against all 14 non-human sequences in the revised matrix.
03 / Revised results

FOXP2 is highly conserved across the selected vertebrates

94.0% conserved

726 of 772 alignment columns were conserved; 46 columns, or 6.0%, varied.

Human–chimp

Pairwise amino-acid identity was 99.72% in the revised analysis.

Broad conservation

Human–zebra finch identity was 98.87%; human–platypus was the reported minimum at 97.46%.

Two human-specific sites

T303N and N325S were reported as human-specific, with the ancestral state retained in all 14 non-human sequences.

Revised pairwise FOXP2 protein identity matrix across 15 vertebrate species
Revised report figure: pairwise identity matrix from the full 772-column MAFFT alignment. This supersedes the fragment-heavy, aggressively trimmed legacy analysis that remains later in the PDF.
04 / Interpretation boundary

The downloadable PDF contains both revised and stale analyses

  • The revised opening summary and figures should control; the later legacy body still lists fragment species such as dog, bat, elephant, and canary.
  • The legacy body reports a 706-column TrimAl alignment and 86 variable sites, which conflict with the revised 772-column full alignment and 46 variable sites.
  • The legacy section says N325S is shared with dog, while the revised analysis reports both T303N and N325S as human-specific.
  • The alligator sequence is partial and may bias comparisons involving terminal positions.
  • High protein identity does not demonstrate a causal mechanism for language, vocal learning, or species-specific behavior; regulatory changes and functional assays are outside this analysis.
Confidence boundary

Use the revised sequence set, matrix, and summary for descriptive comparison. Evolutionary and language-related interpretations remain hypotheses.

05 / Provenance

Revised outputs represented in the session

revised sequence set14 complete proteins plus one labeled partial
full MAFFT alignment772 untrimmed columns
pairwise identity matrixGap-aware identity comparisons
human-specific site reviewT303N and N325S verification
revised figuresUpdated identity and conservation views
Original session report14-page PDF containing revised results followed by the stale legacy body described above.
Download PDF

Run Your Own Analysis

Upload your data and describe your experiment. Pipette manages the analysis and preserves the evidence trail.

Get Started Free